Mic - No, that fishery really isn't worth it.
Will I be there this year - yes, but it will be painfull. We'll take Todd along, and entertain him on the river!
Here's what I can tell you about the Icicle:
First off, regardless of how many fish are at the hatchery, or holding at the mouth of the Icicle, if fish don't run up the Icicle that night, you won't catch anything the next day. It's only when the fish decide to run up the river that night, that fishing is good the next day. Not to say you won't get a fish or two if they are not running, but it makes for long days with very low numbers of fish. Basically, once the fish go, they swim like heck to the hatchery - and they generally don't stop. On the flipside, when the fish have moved up on the previous nights, the next day is just wild - just about everyone will get a fish or twelve.
The Icicle is, by far, the hardest river I have floated to read. I'm pretty damn good at reading water, but I've floated that river with expert guides, and the "fishy" water they pointed out, was nothing even close as to what I would have read as "fishy".
Normally, the rule of thumb is, when you find all the boats anchored up, that's a "good" spot to fish. No boats, no fish.
There are always a ton of bankies and the landowners are mean as hell. Some of the most unfriendliest people I have ever met. I'm pretty sure local "law enforcement" is heavily biased, so all "outsiders" are treated like crap, regardless of anything. There are couple of "honey" holes in which the landowners are notorious A-Holes.
Out of boat, you find an open place to fish (There's really only about 6 or so good spots), anchor up, and basically sit there all day. You'll either get fish, or the fish haven't come up yet and you've wasted the day.
The mouth of the Icicle is always entertaining. When the fish are not moving, they tend to school up at the mouth of the Icicle. You can go there and watch all the sleds cast 1000 yards out in to the mouth of the Wenatchee. Basically, they just sit there and poach. Since they are all "good ol' boys", they are almost always over-looked by the local law enforcement. There's nothing like spending the whole day on the Icicle, not seeing anything caught, and all the folks at the mouth have poached their limits. Nice. "Mind your own FU$*ING business is a common sentence in that area".
Yes, you'll have to launch your boat, in the dark, at 2:00 am, just to get in the water. You will NOT be first person at the honey hole. The land-owners let their friends moore there over night - and a lot of people sleep in their "drift boats" during the weekend.
At least the fish are dark as an old boot! But, the meat is still firm and tastey, and they are fun to fight! Darn this stupid addiction! There *has* to be better things for me to do then go to the Icicle, right????
Parker