i cannot understand why sportfisherman dont understand this

What else would you expect from i buddy Monroe?

how many fall hatchery coho on the columbia do you think the new selective commercial fisherman will be allowed to keep ?

i bet you dont have a clue.

Good theory Chief, but Bill didn't write that editorial.

"Conservation group wants gill-net salmon fishing ban on ballot
By Matthew Preusch, The Oregonian
December 28, 2009, 7:02AM"

Yea I just saw the denial. If you say so.

Oh, gee, does that mean you win?

Marsha, you can continue to characterize it however you like...if it was going to do what the CCA says it will do, then I'd support it...if the Pope was pushing it, I'd disagree with him, too...and if George Dubya Bush was supporting something that I thought made sense, I'd support that, too.

It's not about the organization, it's about the idea. Sorry it's your organization that's fumbling around in the dark on this, but that's the message, not the messenger...

Francis, CCA is selling this as good for springer fishing...and springer fishing will be the biggest loser in this plan, if it works as intended. The springer fishermen who are looking for the CCA to back them up are going to be very disappointed when they get shafted...and that sure won't be good for recruitment.

That's my problem...not that it's a CCA proposal, but that they either can't understand the way seasons are set on the LCR, or if they do they aren't being truthful about the effects of the proposal.

Either way, that's a problem.

Fish on...

Todd

This is your name on that top post isn't it?

Fishy

Hey, Im on Cash Cab with Boater. I need a shout out.

Yes, it is...I wrote the first quote, the second one was written by Keith...stlhdr1...not me...even though the quote says I wrote it.

Fish on...

Todd

do you ever say anything intelligent ?

Todd never said that both quotes were from you, just the top one.

Fishy

I'm at a loss for words.

In that case, then yes, it was me...and if you compare commercial selective fishing on the LCR with sportfishing on the OP, then it just goes to show how little the proponents of this plan understand how seasons are set, how allocations are provided and meted out, and what the difference is between a stock that is commercially fished by non-tribals, and one that is not.

Fish on...

Todd

P.S. Do note, please, that Keith's quote in your post says "posted by Todd" on it, too...not just the one I wrote.

Management, or should I say micro management has helped create this whole mess and you cradling some "wild" fish on one river does not mean that they should continue to be slaughtered on another, regardless of who,why or how.


Fishy

+1

i thought the question i asked the eyedoc was a good question but since you seem to know alot, why dont you answer it ?

Troll alert