Leave the nookie love birds alone!
Well I'll admit it--I'm guilty of using a super heavy weighted fly and strike indicator to fish some of the slower and/or deeper holes on the Stilly--most of the steelhead I've c+r'd this year have come to sparse size 8 lead eye egg-sucking leech patterns. Still, I've always kind of shook my head and grumbled at the guys who fish over kings with such a set-up--don't they know those are chinook? This summer I've seen guys fishing spinning gear (no they didn't have a disability), using eggs and a corkie right along the 530, found empty and half-full shrimp containers during the fly season at a couple of spots, and found fish guts along a salmon hole. From what I've heard and seen most of the offenders are locals. It's hard to maintain any degree of enforcement when the locals' sentiments run against the officers.
It's easy to say they should close it completely--after all, there don't appear to be (m)any hatchery fish around (all of the ones I've c+r'd have been those small Deer Creek natives-- a couple of them with net marks) and without brats there's little sense in offering a summer fishery...My sentiments lean toward a closure, just to protect the chinook, but Dennis Dickson raises a valid point when he says "Closed waters are a poacher's waters."
This is the first year I tried the weighted fly and indicator routine, and found it productive, if a bit more boring to fish than a sinktip. I'd still rather hook a fish on the swing than anything, but right now all my favorite runs have emptied of water (and current) and are showing all their rocks...I've pounded that upper river and found only rocks, an occasional dolly or sucker, and more rocks, and have decided not to fish it again until after a rain. I hope someone else has done better...
I guess all this is by way of saying I'm willing to abide by the rule and shelve my heavy flies, but I'm disappointed that it's necessary, and whether they decide to keep the river open or close it isn't as important as the decision to patrol it and enforce the regs.
On an unrelated note, I drove by the mouth of the Cascade River the other day and noticed a couple of (tribal?) guys fishing the first hole up--in closed waters. I expected to see them using a net, but they were using rods and reels...is this some sort of tribal privilege? Just curious...