Docs system looks great, but the simple Palomar is nearly 100% and a lot less work. Palomar is hard to use with big lures or double hook set-ups.
A simple Palomar or SDJ is definitely the quicker fixer upper if I'm in a hurry to get back in the water, and is certainly plenty strong.
Yup my system seems like it's kind of a PITA, but I use it for a specific but very versatile application on all my boat rods that allows me to very quickly switch my gear out between trolling herring with divers or lead balls, anchor fishing kwiks or wobblers, backtrolling diver/bait or plugs, and/or backbouncing bait all with the same basic foundation. I tie the knots ONCE for the entire season, then use a quick change system of snaps to swivels/snaps pre-tied to leaders and droppers.... thus eliminating ALL need for EVER tying knots in the boat for total efficiency while on the water. It's a convenience that most of my passengers take for granted, but when someone breaks a leader and/or dropper or wants to change presentations in the in the middle of a hot bite, it's really nice to be able to instantaneously get back in the game.
This knot system leaves me a 1.5 - 2.0 ft doubled section of braid where my mainline is going to take the brunt of wear/tear from my slider, weeds, sticks, tangles with the dropper, and friction from the tip-top. It really DOES last all season long, so from the standpoint of tying economy, I'm miles ahead by the end of the season compared to retying the whole setup for all of these various presentations.
Actually with a little practice a 40-50 turn Bimini can be tied in under a minute. Some guys advocate a 12-turn Bimini in braid, but in my hands, more turns definitely performs better. The fNp knot can be tied in about 15-20 seconds... a Palomar in about 10 seconds. Not really a whole lot of time invested for a knot system that will last all the way from springers in March to coho in November.
_________________________
"Let every angler who loves to fish think what it would mean to him to find the fish were gone." (Zane Grey)
"If you don't kill them, they will spawn." (Carcassman)
The Keen Eye MDLong Live the Kings!