Discuss.

Bushmills Vs. Jameson: it's the same company that makes both of them anyway. Pernod-Ricard owns both labels.

As I understand it, one is marketed to Protestants, and the other to Catholics...not sure which is which though.

I prefer Bushmills... has a tad bit o' peatier flavor that warms the soul..But I'm a Scotch guy myself.


Give me a good 12yr+ scotch over both anyday.

Always thought Irish whiskey was a bit of an odd duck.

But I liked it better than scotch, a lighter flavor, kinda delicate. Way different than any American or Canadian whiskey I've ever drank.


Of the two I preferred Jameson straight up, Bushmills I dumped in my coffee w/ Baileys


c/22

Dumped ? Surely you poured...

Scotch.

This is a tough one. Both are excellent, but I think I have decided Jameson is better straight-up, where Bushmills is hard to beat on the rocks. I am also a Scotch guy (or at least I was when I had money to spend on the good stuff), but Irish works just fine in a pinch.

Pinch is a scotch.

Ech. Scotch.

I'd tell my tale o' Scotch but I'm not sure about the statutes of limitations.

Redbreast all the way!

Makers Mark for whiskey and McCallans for scotch.

i've still got about 2 drinks worth in my bottle, that i bought back when i was making the big bucks. that stuff blows jameson away(and i like jameson).

Last night, Jameson was for the car bombs, and Bushmills was on the rocks.

Real alcoholics don't care about flavor.

Pendleton for Canadian/American Wickee, and Jameson's for Irish

Makers Mark is bourbon.

what ever you got, i'll drink it. thats no joke!

i'd like to hear edgar's opinion on this.

This is the way i roll.

"Makers Mark is bourbon."

Which is whiskey.

ok how about some input from jonas then. since edgar flaked on not replying.